Oscar Category Strategy for ‘Hamnet’: Should Paul Mescal Be Lead or Supporting?
Why Hamnet Is Turning Heads This Awards Season
When Chloë Zhao’s adaptation of Maggie O’Farrell’s novel hit the festival circuit, the reaction was immediate and intense. Set in 1613 England, the film follows William Shakespeare as he confronts the sudden death of his only son, Hamnet. Critics are calling it a “masterpiece of grief,” noting how the crisp cinematography and sparse score amplify the story’s emotional weight.
Central to that acclaim is Paul Mescal, who steps into Shakespeare’s shoes with a blend of charisma and vulnerability that many reviewers describe as “breathtaking.” An 8.4 rating on aggregate sites reflects a consensus: Mescal’s performance feels raw, yet meticulously crafted, making each scene feel lived‑in rather than performed.
The Lead‑Supporting Debate and Studio Strategy
Behind the glowing reviews, a tactical battle is unfolding in the awards office. Studios must decide whether to push Mescal for a Best Actor nomination or to position him in the Supporting Actor category, where competition may be slightly less fierce.
Three factors dominate the discussion:
- Screen Time: While Mescal appears in roughly 60% of the film’s runtime, the narrative is deliberately ensemble‑driven, giving significant weight to Jessie Buckley’s Lady Shakespeare and Jacobi Jupe’s Hamnet.
- Character Arc: Some argue that Shakespeare’s personal journey is the film’s emotional anchor, qualifying Mescal as the lead. Others point out that the story is truly about collective mourning, suggesting a supporting label.
- Category Competition: The Best Actor field this year includes heavy‑hitting names from blockbuster dramas, whereas the Supporting category looks more open, increasing the odds of a win.
Studios are also weighing the impact of early‑season festival awards. A win at Venice or Toronto can swing momentum toward a lead nomination, while a strong showing at the Critics’ Choice Awards may boost a supporting push.
Beyond Mescal, the film’s overall awards strategy hinges on its technical strengths. Zhao’s direction, the period‑accurate production design, and the evocative score are all considered Oscar‑worthy. Campaign teams are bundling these elements into a cohesive narrative that positions *Hamnet* as a serious contender for Best Picture, even as the lead‑supporting debate continues.
As the calendar ticks toward nomination deadlines, the industry watches to see which path the studio will choose. The decision could set a precedent for how period dramas with ensemble casts are positioned in future awards seasons.
About Author
